CABLEFAX CABLEFAX MAGAZINE CABLEFAX DAILY COMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGY

Regulation  |  Deals/Finance  |  Affiliates  |  Advanced Services  |  Operators/MSOs  |  Marketing
SMART VIEW: VIDEO | VOICE | DATA | WIRELESS | MOST READ
SEARCH: Advanced Search

May 15, 2006

Government: Definitions

Classic literature is judged by its ability to stand the test of time. Legislation that regulates technology rarely passes that test.

We've heard the phrase "the devil is in the details," a variant on "God is in the details." That could not be truer than when it comes to government telecommunications rules and regulations. Actually, it's not simply the details, it's the definitions.

If you look at the raging battles surrounding "rewrites" of the Telecommunications Act, or the court suits regarding cable, what you will notice most is they are about the definition of terms in the laws, rules and regulations. The problem is that when those laws and rules were written, the terms referred to then-current technology. As we know, by the time the ink is dry on regulations regarding telecommunications the technology has already moved on. So the challenge is to apply old words to new technology. It rarely works well.

You wouldn't think, for instance, that it would be hard to define "cable television." But there are now court suits over whether "IPTV" is "cable" for the purposes of applying rules that say cable providers must have a local franchise before they can offer "cable service." The most recent effort by AT&T to avoid the franchise requirement by arguing that its "IPTV" offering is not "cable" got thrown out of court in California recently. The decision did not rely on defining the term, however.

At the same time, AT&T is arguing its "IPTV" service is "cable" when the question arises in the context of copyright! So the definition changes depending on which law AT&T is relying on.

These arguments are not new. In the broadest sense, the FCC has been struggling for years to define the difference between an "information service" and a "telecommunications service." The intent is to regulate different (often new) services in different ways, to give new services some relief from older, encrusted statutes. It's a laudatory effort, but is bound to fail. Changing definitions to reflect new regulatory policies creates more confusion and additional layers of legal complexity.

Some in Congress are suggesting a better approach: Get rid of the complex rules and regulations now that the telephone, cable, satellite and broadcasting industries along with the Internet are competing vigorously with each other to deliver communications services of one sort or another to consumers. Let the market operate and use the antitrust laws to rein in any "bad actors." It's an idea worth considering, but since it would be a radical departure from telecom overregulation, and there are already several more traditional bills being considered, it's unlikely to get serious consideration in this congressional session. Of course that depends on your definition of "serious."

Steve Effros is a columnist and consultant in the cable television industry, and is a former FCC attorney and president of CATA. He can be reached at steve@effros.com.





MORE REGULATION




SERVICES







Read about the winners of CableFAX: The Magazine's 2008 CableFAXIES Awards, and find out who's working at the top of their game in cable PR and marketing.




Reprint Inquires for CableFAX: The Magazine, please contact Lyndsay Bahn lyndsay.bahn@theYGSgroup.com 717-666-3052.

For extra copies of CableFAX: The Magazine, please contact clientservices@accessintel.com or 800-777-5006.







       


Add a Comment

Name:
Email:
Comments:

Please enter the letters or numbers you see in the image.
 
   Your message will be reviewed before it is posted


  AWARDS


CableFAX: The Magazine Top Op Awards

Honoring the winning picks of Cable's top MSO and Independent Operators.

See our top picks and be sure to place your advertising to reach this top audience in CableFAX: The Magazine's annual Top Ops issue, July 26, 2009.

Ad Close: July 9
Artwork: July 13

View 2009 "Top Ops" Winners and See Ad Rates 

The Top Ops Issue will include a Special Report
profiling Faith & Values Programmers



  WEBINARS
Wireless: The Next Five Years
July 16, 2009

[Register]

Fiber Optic Access: RFog and PON Update
July 30, 2009

[Register]

The "TV Everywhere" Debate: Will Authentication Save the Online Video Model?

June 17, 2009
[Register]


Advanced Advertising: Next Steps

Now Available On Demand
Free Webcast - Presented by Communications Technology
[On Demand]

How Cable Can Monetize Web Video, Social Networking & Other Online Activities
[On Demand]


  EVENTS
CableFAX Onsite Workshop
Social Media Bootcamp
July 16, 2009
New York
Register Now


CableFAX 
Sales Executive
of the Year
Awards and
Sweet 16
Breakfast


June 11, 2009 Grand Hyatt
New York


 
  E-LETTERS
Sign-Up Today!

The Skinny from CableFAX
Cable news in a quick-read format


Cable360 Direct
industry news and updates

CT Reports
developments in voice, video, & data 
INSIDE
CABLE360.NET:
Business
Programming
Technology
Competition
Calendar
Resources

AWARDS, E-NEWSLETTERS, EVENTS & SPECIAL ISSUES
Award Programs
E-Newaletter & Subscriptions
Events
Webinar From CableFAX
Webinars From Communications Technology
CableFAX: The Magazine
Special Issues from Communications Technology

INDUSTRY JOBS & OPENINGS:
 

PUBLICATIONS AND RESOURCES
CableFAX Daily

CableFAX.com

Communications Technology

CableFAX: The Magazine
  Home | Business | Programming | Technology | Competition | Minisites | Webinars | Calendar | Jobs | Resources
Subscribe | Contact | About Us | Privacy & Terms | Advertising | Site Map
CABLE360 © 2009 Access Intelligence LLC. All Rights Reserved.